CONTESTS   |   SEARCH   |   SUBMIT   |   POSTERS   |   STORE   |   LINKS   |   EXTRA

 

 

 

 

 

English Patient, The - Collector's Series  (1996)

 

Starring: Ralph Fiennes, Juliette Binoche, Willem Dafoe, Kristin Scott Thomas, Naveen Andrews, Colin Firth

Director: Anthony Minghella

Rating: R

Distributor: Buena Vista Home Entertainment

Release Date: June 29, 2004
Review posted: June 29, 2004

Spoilers: Minor

 

Reviewed by Dylan Grant

 

SYNOPSIS

 

During World War II, a mysterious stranger (Ralph Fiennes) is cared for by British allies unaware of his dangerous past. As the mystery of his identity is revealed, an incredible tale of passion, intrigue and adventure unfolds.

 

CRITIQUE

 

The English Patient is classical filmmaking, which is to say that it calls to mind the great epics of Hollywood’s Golden Age, David Lean’s Lawrence of Arabia in particular. In this highly poetic film, director Anthony Minghella takes us through the layers of a great mystery, subtly revealing more and more, until that mystery has been solved and only the wounds remain.

 

The film opens at the pivotal moment in two lives, a pre-war bi-plane flying over the desert carrying two passengers. The film will tell us who these two are, the rest of the film telling us what led up to that flight and what came after. Minghella skews the timeline in a way that only cinema is capable of. The present day action involves Hana (Juliette Binoche), a French-Canadian nurse in Italy who stays behind to care for the mysterious patient. She creates a makeshift church in an old monastery. This “English patient” comes to remind Hana of other men she has lost during the war. She is joined at the monastery by Kip (Naveen Andrews), a Sikh officer working with a bomb disposal unit, and Caravaggio (Willem Dafoe), a mysterious visitor who has an interest in the morphine Hana dispenses to her patient. Spurred on by the book that was found with his charred body in the wreckage of his plane, Hana’s mysterious patient starts to regain his memory in flashes of detail.

 

The back-story comes together gradually, told by this dying man in a bed. The performances in The English Patient really make the film. Binoche is a woman so affected by the war that she finds herself drawn to its wounded. Dafoe gives one of his best performances as the mysterious Caravaggio, a man whose motives remain murky for most of the film – as they should – but who we see clearly harboring much anger. Minghella has creatively adapted a book that was widely considered unfilmable, staying true to the heart of the material while giving a sumptuous visual feast worthy of the ages.

 

The English Patient will hold your attention, but there are instances where the pacing just does not hold up, and any scale of how rewatchable a film might be, The English Patient ranks low. Minghella, producer Saul Zaentz and the actors have given us a great film, but it is one that requires strict attention. The story is intricately woven, but it goes on too long in places. Despite its faults, The English Patient is an epic film, and it is definitely worth the time for anyone who appreciates great filmmaking.

 

THE VIDEO

 

The English Patient is presented in 1.85:1 anamorphic widescreen. The transfer really preserves the rich depth of the photography, with all color grades represented expertly. There is some minor grain in places, which is surprising, considering the overall care that went into this set. Overall, though, this is a fantastic transfer. Optional subtitles are available in Spanish and French.

 

THE AUDIO

 

The audio is presented here in DTS 5.1 Digital Surround and Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound. The presentation is crisp, with clear dispersal through all channels. The sound is exceptionally clean.

 

THE EXTRAS

 

The features we get with The English Patient are exhaustive in detail, with an entire second disc devoted to bonus material. There is little left unturned when it comes to background information. About the only thing missing is the original theatrical trailer.

 

Commentary by writer/director Anthony Minghella: He talks about each scene, adapting the book, how he chose the music, the actors, and how certain decisions were made. A detailed talk about the film.

 

Commentary by writer/director Anthony Minghella, producer Saul Zaentz, and Michael Ondaatje: The three men most responsible about the film go into great detail here, but this track covers a lot of the same bases as Minghella’s solo commentary.

 

Master class with writer/director Anthony Minghella (includes deleted scenes): Deleted scenes with context given by Minghella. He outlines each scene and talks abut the decisions that led to their deletion.

 

CBC Documentary “The Making of The English Patient”: A behind-the-scenes look at the making of the film. We hear from Minghella and all the principle participants. Gives some details, but this is not very entertaining.

 

Author Michael Ondaatje featurette: The other of the source novel on how he came to writing, how he evolved from poetry to prose and the process of adapting the book.

 

Producer Saul Zaentz featurette: Perhaps the shortest piece on the disc, this features Minghella and the principle actors talking about the joy and encouragement of working with Zaentz.

 

Production designer Stuart Craig featurette: Craig talks about creating the world of The English Patient from the ground up. What he has to say is pretty interesting.

 

A historical look at the real Count Almasy: An interesting look at figure behind the book and film. They talk about his exploits during and before the North African campaign in World War II. This piece is definitely worth a look.

 

“From Novel to Screenplay”: This short feature has the cast and crew talking about the experience of reading the book and creating the film. Clips from the film are shown.

 

Filmmaker Conversations: Anthony Minghella, Saul Zaentz, Michael Ondaatje, and editor Walter Murch talk about their experiences making the film, reading the book, and how some artistic decisions were made. Some of what they have to say is interesting, some of it is downright boring.

 

The Eyes of Phil Brady – Still Photographer: Rarely do we get to hear from the still photographer. Here Brady talks about his 20 year association with Zaentz and what goes in to his job on the set. This is worth watching for a peek into an aspect of filmmaking that we rarely hear about.

 

Reviews: Reviews of The English Patient from Roger Ebert, Peter Travers of Rolling Stone, and David Thompson of Esquire.

 

FINAL THOUGHTS

 

The English Patient is an example of excellence in filmmaking at all levels. The depth of the special features is something that we can only wish was given to most DVD releases. Only the film’s lack of rewatchability lowers its rating. It is worth seeing, but only a few will want to see it more than once.

 

VERDICT: RECOMMENDED

 

Home | Back to Top

 

:: The Disc

 

:: Disc Ratings

 

THE MOVIE

8

THE VIDEO

9

THE AUDIO

9

THE EXTRAS

9

OVERALL

8

 

:: Merchandise

 

FILM SCORE

By Gabriel Yared

Buy the CD!

 

THE NOVEL

Buy the Book!