|
Something the
Lord Made
(2004)
Rating:
NR
Distributor:
HBO Home Video
Release
Date: January 25, 2005
Review posted: January 25, 2005
Reviewed by
Dylan Grant
SYNOPSIS
The true story
of two men who defied the rules of their time to launch a medical
revolution, set against the backdrop of the Jim Crow south. Working
in 1940’s Baltimore on an unprecedented technique for performing heart
surgery on “blue babies,” Dr. Alfred Blalock (Alan Rickman) and Vivian
Thomas (Mos Def) for an impressive team. But even as they race
against time to save a dying baby, the two occupy very different
places in society. Blalock is a wealthy white Head of Surgery at
Johns Hopkins; Thomas is black and poor, a skilled carpenter. As
Blalock and Thomas invent a new field of medicine, saving thousands of
lives in the process, social pressures threaten to undermine their
collaboration and their friendship apart.
CRITIQUE
“Blue baby”
was a term given to children with cyanotic heart disease, a condition
that limits the amount of oxygen traveling from the heart to the
lungs. For thousands of children over an untold number of years, this
was a killer; the mortality rate was 100%. Conventional wisdom of the
day said that operating on the heart was impossible. Thankfully for
the rest of humanity, Dr. Alfred Blalock and Vivian Thomas dared to
challenge the old ways of thinking. The two overcame much, inventing
not only the procedures, but the very equipment used to perform the
surgery.
The medical
quest is the most interesting part of this story. The racial backdrop
is interesting, but it has been done so many times that it is easily
overshadowed by the struggles of two men in a laboratory. Everything
is well balanced. When Blalock’s colleagues tell him that a heart
operation cannot be done, the fact that he is partnered with a black
man is almost never mentioned. The other doctors doubt Blalock simply
because they have no reason to believe that cardiological surgery can
be successful. The racial politics are kept low key: Vivian has to
enter through a different door, use a different bathroom, et cetera.
Perhaps this is for the best. When Vivian and Blalock are in the lab,
they are thinking about medicine, and politics are of little
importance.
This leads to
some interesting medical drama. In order to cure the blue baby
syndrome, the two must first figure out a way to recreate the
condition in a dog (they experimented on strays), and then they
had to figure out how to cure it. All the while, actual children with
the condition were just down the hall, never allowing the two to
forget the stakes. Their work was truly groundbreaking; there was
absolutely no precedent for what they were doing. Vivian and Blalock
had no way of knowing it would work until it actually worked.
The scene
where they perform the first human procedure is thick with tension, as
it should be; it is the strongest scene in the film. Not
surprisingly, when the procedure is a success, it is the white Blalock
that gets all the credit, the adulation of the medical community, the
cover of Life magazine, and everything that goes with it.
Blalock may not have forgotten Vivian, but the rest of the world did,
if it ever knew he existed in the first place. As the years wore on,
times changed, and politically things improved. Johns Hopkins heaped
praise on Vivian, including an honorary doctorate, and they hung his
portrait next to Blalock’s.
In the lead
roles, Alan Rickman and Mos Def are great together. Their chemistry
works, and it comes off well on screen. The writing is solid and the
direction assured. The biggest problem with this film is that,
medical history aside, it all seems so familiar, so straightforward.
A film like this probably cannot help but to repeat the same themes,
and when the story and the characters are this good it is hard to
complain. One just wishes the whole thing came off as anything other
than a foregone conclusion.
THE
VIDEO
Something
the Lord Made is
presented in the original 1.85:1 shooting ratio. The transfer is
sharp, with no grains or defects present. The color levels are
properly transferred, and the overall picture is crisp.
THE
AUDIO
This DVD
offers several audio options: English 5.1, English 2.0, French 2.0 and
Spanish 2.0. The audio presentation is solid. While there are no big
sound effects here to push your surround sound system, the clarity is
sharp, and all levels come through as they should.
THE
EXTRAS
Audio
Commentary by Director Joseph Sargent, Writer Peter Silverman, and
Executive Producers Robert W. Cort and Eric Hetzel:
The men responsible for the film talk about how the project came to
fruition and what their intentions were. They talk about working with
the actors and give a little insight into the real life events that
inspired the film.
Featurette: A short behind-the-scenes look at the making of the film. The actors
talk about creating their roles and some basic information about the
real Thomas and Blalock is given. This feature is not that
interesting. Aside from not even having a title, it is barely four
minutes in length, and what the principals have to say is superficial.
Making
History Slideshow: Photos
of the real Blalock and Thomas with captions describing what they went
through.
The features
on this disc are not bad, but they add nothing to the film. The
slideshow is too short to be of much interest, and the other two
features are standard fare.
FINAL
THOUGHTS
Something
the Lord Made is a good
film, and that is about the best that can be said about it. The story
is straightforward, and it is one that, aside from the moment in
history in which it takes place, is one that we have seen many times
before. Of course, when the story and the actors are this good, one
can only complain so much. The features on this disc leave something
to be desired, and little would be missed by not indulging in them.
This is a well-made film if you have the time.
VERDICT:
RECOMMENDED
Home | Back to
Top |