CONTESTS   |   SEARCH   |   SUBMIT   |   POSTERS   |   STORE   |   LINKS   |   EXTRA

 

 

 

 

 

Q & A with Nancy Meyers

 

This roundtable Q&A session for the DVD release of "Something's Gotta Give" was conducted on March 15, 2004.

 


DVD REVIEW: Something's Gotta Give


 

Q:  I guess I'd ask about the deleted karaoke scene.  How's it come about in the story, originally?  And why did that get cut out?  And also, what's the song being played?  That sounded familiar to me.

 

NANCY MEYERS:  Well, "La Vie En Rose” is the song.  And I wrote it into the screenplay.  And you know, you shoot everything that you've written.  And then you have to cut your movie down.  And my first cut of the movie was about two hours and forty-five minutes, and the picture came out at about two hours and, I don't know what it is, six or seven minutes.  So things have to go.  And then you just sort of weigh what you need against what you don't need to tell your story.  And although I loved that scene, and I loved Jack in it, and he worked very hard on it, it just didn't seem like I needed it to tell my story.  And when things had to go, unfortunately, I took it out.  That's really the story behind it. 

 

Q:  If you thought about - did you think about that being able to be available to people on the DVD?  And was there any other out takes you thought about trying to have on there?

 

NANCY MEYERS:  Did I think about it being on the DVD, what do you mean?

 

Q:  You know, when you were cutting, you know...

 

NANCY MEYERS:  Yes?  Oh no, I didn't think, "Oh I'll lose it here, but save it for the DVD."  But when, the DVD people at Columbia came to me and said, "Do you want to put in any deleted scenes," I've never done that before. But on this movie, more than any other movie, the scenes I cut were often as good as the scenes I kept.  So this scene, because you get to see Jack Nicholson sing, is very unique.  You know, I think he sang in one other movie, in "Heartburn," Mike Nichols' movie.  So I thought, you know, for Nicholson fans, it offers a unique moment. 

 

But I didn't put in other deleted scenes, because I don't know, there's something - you know, when you cut a scene from a movie, you never really finish cutting it.  You don't perfect it and then cut it, you know?  So I never really had finished a lot of the other scenes that I had cut.  So that's why they didn't make it onto the DVD.  Even the karaoke scene that you see is not the entire song of "La Vie En Rose," because I never figured out a way to use the entire song.  It was too long.  So this is an abbreviated version of the song.  So, real fans of the song will know that some of the lyric is missing.

 

Photo Gallery

Nancy Meyers and Jack Nicholson on the set.

 

Q:  I had like two quick questions - one getting back to Jack Nicholson, and then one on the film in general.  Actually, I thought Jack Nicholson sang fairly well, because he's on the sound track.  And you hear, "La Vie En Rose." But it's funny because Ebert and Roper kind of said, "Don't lose your day job," when they reviewed the DVD over the weekend.  Any thought about - because you know, I think he has a very charming - it's very kind of unschooled singing style.  But it's very genuine.  And you know - I don't know.  I think he did a great job.

 

NANCY MEYERS:  Well, yes.  I mean he's not a singer; he's an actor.  And the intent was not to showcase Jack as a singer.

 

NANCY MEYERS: The scene was in the movie because he was expressing affection for Erica (ph), and trying to give her a gift.  And since she was a fan of this kind of music, he was going to sing one of these songs for her as a thank you for saving his life.  So, you know, the scene was not taken out because Jack, you know, wasn't Franks Sinatra, or Yves Montand.

 

NANCY MEYERS:  You know, that was not the point.

 

Q:  Yes.  And actually another sound track question - did you have anything to do with the selection of songs?  Because it was really eclectic, and I thought very well done in terms of advancing the feelings of the film or the emotions.  And also, there were just some unusual talents that are not heard in the States so much, like Coralee Clement (ph), and I'm trying to think of whom else off the top of my head.

 

NANCY MEYERS:  Well, I had very talented music supervisors working on the film, and they brought me a tremendous amount of music to listen to.  And finally, those were the ones that I picked that I thought worked the best.  But some of those songs were, you know, actually found by other people and brought to my attention.  Sort of like casting a movie, the way a casting director brings you actors to choose from.  That's what a music supervisor does.  Some of the songs were in my screenplay, and some were replaced.  And some brand new ones were found.  And there's even a song in there that was Jack's idea.

 

Q:  Really, which one?

 

NANCY MEYERS:  The song that plays when they're kissing, "I Only Have Eyes For You."

 

NANCY MEYERS:  Yes.  That was Jack's idea.

 

Q:  And then, one quick question about the film in general.  You know, it was wonderful that Diane Keaton got an Oscar nomination.  And I mean, I think I'm one of the few people thought, "Well, she should have gotten the Oscar too."

 

Photo Gallery

Diane Keaton and Nancy Meyers on the set.

 

NANCY MEYERS:  Well I don't think you're the only one that thought that.  If she wouldn't have, you know ...

 

Q:  Yes, gotten the ...

 

NANCY MEYERS:  If she wouldn't have gotten the nomination, I know, certainly, many people thought that she did a great job in the movie – very touching, very funny. 

 

Q:  Yes, yes.  I mean, do you feel, in a way, it was unfortunate that you have such a wonderful part for her, and that, you know, just as fate would have it, she's going up against this particular movie.  I mean, I know there's really nothing - I mean that's just the way it happened.

 

NANCY MEYERS:  That’s the way the cookie crumbles.

 

NANCY MEYERS: It's always great for me to look back on films and say, "That person was never nominated?" I remember when Cary Grant won an Oscar, because he had never gotten one.  You know?  So, thanks for saying that.  I appreciate it.  I'm really proud of her performance. 

 

Q:  My question was, did you expect the film to be as well received as it was?  And how do you feel now that you do have all these nominations under your belt with this fantastic film?

 

NANCY MEYERS:  Thanks.  I feel very proud.  This movie has brought more good things to me than any movie I've done.  It's been, in some ways, you know - I don't want this to be misconstrued - but, heartwarming, you know, that women in particular have responded so strongly.  People have written me and said that this movie reflected something in their lives, or touched them in a way.  So it's been very gratifying, very, very gratifying. 

 

And right before it came out, there were a few articles in the paper and the "Wall Street Journal," wondering who in the hell was going to go see a movie about middle-aged people who fall in love.  And it was too late then because we were about to open.  But it was a bit surprising for me that the film was getting that kind of watchful eye.  People in Hollywood were really watching to see what would happen.  And then you know, at the last minute, I got nervous.  I thought, "Wow, what if they're right?  What if people aren't going to come?"

 

And it didn't have a huge splashy opening, certainly.  But it just hung in the theater.  It just stayed and grew, and in an unusual way. Not in the way most films make it.  Films generally open, if they're going to be a hit, they open very strongly.  And then they fall off.  And we didn't have that kind of pattern with this movie.  So it was great.  What can I say? 

 

Q:  And to follow that up, you know, what kind of inspired you to write this story?  Was there something in particular that led you to write this?

 

NANCY MEYERS:  Well, what led me to write it was, really my own life.  You know, I've been writing movies since I'm (ph) 29.  And I'm 54 now.  And I found this is what interested me at this point in my life.  You know, just like when I wrote "Private Benjamin," when I was young, about a woman going off on her own, and not getting married.  All those things seemed so vital to me then.  This is a story that seemed vital to the life I lead now, that's all.

 

Q:  I wanted to follow up - now I thought that I'd read that you'd created - or you really had Diane Keaton in mind when you put the role together.  Is that true?

 

NANCY MEYERS:  Yes.  I had Diane and Jack in mind.  Those were really the only actors I wanted for this movie.

 

Q:  Yes.  Now, can you - and I know you had a lot of static from the studio thinking, "OK, what was Diane Keaton's last hit?" You know, there was reluctance to cast here, thinking that she's not bankable enough.  Well that was proven wrong.  Now, considering the success of this film, do you have anything else in the works, for Diane Keaton?  Or ...

 

NANCY MEYERS:  No I don't.  But I hope this isn't our last movie together.  We've made four films together.  And I hope to make another one with her.  But I don't have anything for her in my immediate future.

 

Q:  Yes.  OK.  And can you speak a little bit about the whole studio reluctance to cast her originally, because to me ...

 

NANCY MEYERS:  Well, you know, my argument was easy and simple, really.  When they didn't immediately want Diane, I said, "Well what 55-year-old woman is going to make them line up around the corner for this movie?"

 

NANCY MEYERS:  And basically, there's no answer to that.  There isn't one. Diane now is the biggest box-office star her age.  And you know, when I posed that question, there were answers, but not great ones.  I said, "So let's cast the person that's right for it, and the person that's going to make the movie great, and the person I wrote it for.  Let's not screw it up now.  Let's keep going." And you know, it wasn't a long, hard fight.  They did really love Diane, you know?

 

NANCY MEYERS:  Right.  And it's hopeful.  I mean besides the fact that it reflects reality, it's also hopeful for people in middle age that, if they're single - and there are a lot of us that are single – that your life isn't over.

 

Q: I had another question about the DVD itself.  Directors, occasionally either, you know may say they dislike or like doing commentaries.  And for this one, you did two.

 

NANCY MEYERS:  Yes.

 

Q:  Talk about what you think of doing them and the difference in chatting with Jack Nicholson on one hand, and Diane Keaton and Bruce Block on the other.  Did they have different feels as you were doing them?

 

NANCY MEYERS:  What did you think of those commentaries?

 

Q:  Well, I've only got to listen about an hour of each one, because I've got only so much time.  But you know, I think I would definitely want to listen to the entire Jack Nicholson one, if I was a Jack Nicholson fan.  And I am.  So I want to go back and hear that.  But then, I think I may have learned more about film making in the other, though Jack has some interesting actor insights that I had heard in what I've listened to.

 

NANCY MEYERS:  Yes.  That's what I thought, too.  Well yes, it's an odd experience, watching your movie so soon after making it, and then talking about it.  The good news is that you still remember everything really well.  But it's odd to confront your film that way, and to dissect it and talk about it.  Because you know, you can bring back too many memories and then the commentary probably won't be too interesting then.

 

What was really cool about having Diane there was that she'd never seen the movie.  I showed it to her in a longer form at about two-and-a-half hours, which I like to do with the actors.  Before I'm finished, I like to show them the movie, because if they hate a take that I've chosen - I mean, after all they, they work for six months and then, you know, the director chooses everything.  You know, and there could be something that she could say, "Oh man, you know, I hate the way I did that."

 

So I'd done that with Diane, but she never saw the finished film before doing her commentary.  And so it was fun to sit with her while she's watching the movie, because, since you may notice on the DVD, she's laughing at things, just like the audience did, because she's never really seen it.  So that was a unique experience.  And I was sort of beaming just watching her watch the movie. 

 

And with Jack, it was just a great time for me, because I got to sit with a master actor, and listen to him talk about acting.  And Jack has never been on television.  He's never done a talk show.  He hasn’t done the Actor's Studio.  It's a public record of this great actor talking about what he goes through in a scene to get his performance.  And his observations about the other actors - I thought, for actors, you know, this is a great tool for them.  So I was just thrilled with how that came out.

 

Q:  How hard was it to get him to do that?

 

NANCY MEYERS:  I asked him.

 

NANCY MEYERS:  I just asked him, but he couldn't make it on the day Diane was coming.  I think he was playing golf or something.

 

NANCY MEYERS:  So he did it the next day.  And I was glad that it worked out that way.  As soon as we got rolling, I realized this was going to be a whole other take than the first commentary.  And since I'd already done my commentary, I didn't have to talk about my end of things.  So I could just talk to him about him in the movie.

 

Q:  One of my co-writers I work with said you know there was some - said I should ask you about the idea of keeping the movie to a PG 13 rating.  Were there any thoughts to lengthen any scenes for the DVD, if you wanted to either do an R rating or anything like that?

 

NANCY MEYERS:  No I don't have that kind of footage.

 

NANCY MEYERS:  There was something I did have to - oh yes, I know what it was.  Diane's nude scene - it was originally three seconds that we saw her in the nude.  And the Ratings Board thought it was too long, and I cut a second out of it, which doesn't sound like a lot.  But in that kind of a shot, it's quite significant.  And so it went from three seconds to two seconds, and they approved it.  But no, I didn't think to lengthen that for the DVD.

 

Q:  Well I mean, you think of DVDs, you know, with movies like "The Matrix," and things, and looking at special affects and things.  But do you think people will be freeze-framing that scene to see how you did it, to see what more they see?

 

NANCY MEYERS:  Oh, there's nothing that I did.  I just turned on the camera, and she ran through, you know.  Do you think people will freeze it? I'm sure she would be very flattered if they did.

 

Q:  All right.  Well thanks.

 

NANCY MEYERS:  OK, take care.

 


 

Home | Back to Top

 

:: Buy the DVD

 

:: Merchandise