|
Brown Bunny,
The
(2004)
Starring:
Vincent Gallo,
Chloë
Sevigny
Director: Vincent Gallo
Rating: NR
Distributor:
Wellspring
Release Date:
08.27.04
Review
Posted: 08.27.04
Spoilers:
Minor
By
Dylan Grant
The most notorious work to come out of the 2003
Cannes Film Festival, The Brown Bunny is finally out for
all to see. At Cannes, the film was reviled, hated by the
audiences there and prompting critic Roger Ebert to say that it
was the worst film he had ever seen at Cannes, and he compared
it to his recent colonoscopy. (Ebert has more recently said
that the new cut of the film, the one that was released Friday,
is better than the Cannes version, and not quite as bad as he
originally said it was, but that it is still a bad film.) Most
of what has circled since has been driven by rumor: nothing
happens, it’s pretentious in the extreme, all of the talk
inevitably coming to focus on the blowjob scene at the end of
the film. The climax is the climax, har har.
There is so
much more going on in the film than that. The Brown Bunny
calls to mind the minimalist films of the 1970’s, particularly
Two-Lane Blacktop and Vanishing Point. The story concerns
motorcycle racer Bud Clay (Gallo), who, after his latest race, is on
his way from New Hampshire to Los Angeles. Along the way he meets
Violet, Lilly, and Rose, women who are all sharing space with Bud on
the highway to nowhere. Not only do their names call Daisy to Bud’s
mind, but each of the women also bares some resemblance to her. It is
as if Bud is really running into three incarnations of Daisy at each
of his stops. (The first girl, Violet, who he meets at a gas station,
even bares a striking physical resemblance to her.) It is probably a
good thing that we know there will be a graphic sex scene at the end
of the film. It adds a layer of suspense to everything that is going
on. The scene where Bud pays a visit to Daisy’s elderly parents is
immediately intriguing. The three of them sit awkwardly in the
kitchen, Daisy’s mother unable to remember anything about Bud, even
though he grew up in the house next door and frequented their house.
She barely remembers a trip she took to California to visit them. It
is sad enough when she babbles, “I haven't heard from her, she hasn't
called. I don't know why she hasn't called,” but knowing what is
coming makes it all the more heartbreaking. Scenes such as this make
one think that the film almost works better on a second viewing.
Gallo
perfectly captures the road, the feeling of being alone on the road
for long stretches of time, and how all that time alone can play
tricks on the mind. As his trip progresses, as Bud becomes more and
more out of touch with reality, we go from the lush greens of New
England and the Midwest, to the stark, barren browns of the deserts of
the west. Through it all we are drenched in the mind numbing sameness
that permeates the trip, that permeates every long road trip. By the
time Bud arrives in Los Angeles, we may have decided that he is
clinically insane. He leaves a note on the door of Daisy’s house and
tells the front desk at his hotel that she might be coming by and to
send her up. Of course, we know that she is not going to come by,
that this is impossible, but Bud is convinced.
To try and
talk about The Brown Bunny with talking about the film’s
climactic sex scene is like trying to talk about The Birth of a
Nation without bringing up the Ku Klux Klan. In the context of
the film, the scene is wholly necessary, and is in fact a bit
disturbing, knowing that this graphic scene – graphic not only in
sexual terms, but also in terms of the demeaning way in which he talks
to Daisy – is going on entirely inside Bud’s head. The final
flashback, where we see how Bud ran away scared when Daisy needed him
the most, is strikingly poignant.
The Brown Bunny
is by no means a perfect film, and it is definitely not for all
tastes, but it is a sharply realized, well directed film that renders
emotion subtly, letting the viewer find it for himself rather than
having it beaten out of him. The film has had an unfortunate
reputation for all the wrong reasons, and now that it is available for
us all to see, hopefully that will be put to rest.
Film
Rating:
êêê (out of
4)
Home | Back to Top |