|
A Fond Kiss
(2004)
Director: Ken Loach
Rating: R
Distributor:
Lions Gate Home Video
Release Date:
03.15.05
Review
Posted:
03.25.05
By
Howard Schumann
Roisin Hanlon (Eva
Birthisle) is a spunky young Irish woman who teaches music at a
Glasgow Catholic school. She is still married but no longer lives with
her husband, a situation that will later affect her tenure at the
school. After a fracas at school in which a young Muslim girl is being
chased by bullies, she meets and begins a relationship with Casim Khan
(Atta Yaqub), a Pakistani disc jockey in
Glasgow clubs who plans to open his own club. A Fond Kiss
is the third in the
Glasgow series by
director Ken Loach and screenwriter Paul Lavery (My Name is Joe,
Sweet Sixteen). It is much lighter in tone than his
previous films and avoids scenes of poverty, drugs, and urban decay,
characteristic of many of his other films. Though A Fond Kiss
is basically a romantic drama, it has a great deal to say about issues
of class, race, and religion and does so in a very forthright manner.
Casim, a
second-generation Pakistani, is very close to his parents, Tariq and
Sadia (Ahmad Riaz and Shamshad Akhtar) and his two sisters, Rukhsana (Ghizala
Avan) and Tahara (Shabana Bakhsh). Rukhsana is expected to marry Amar,
a scientist from a prominent family in an arranged marriage, while
Tahara rebels against her parents wishes for her to become a doctor
and plans on studying Journalism at the
University of
Edinburgh.
His relationship with Roisin is opposed by his family who has arranged
a marriage between him and a Pakistani girl and have built an
extension to the family home for them to live in.
The relationship
between Roisin and Casim becomes more intense when they travel to
Spain for a short vacation. Near the end of the trip, however, he
tells her that he is engaged to marry in nine weeks, a marriage
arranged by his family that cannot be canceled. Roisin feels betrayed
by Casim's revelation and seems unable to understand how torn Casim is
between his devotion to his parents and his growing love for her.
Newcomer Birthisle does an excellent job in portraying a tough-minded
independent woman who is willing to stand up to social pressure and be
true to her deepest feelings. "It will break their hearts, destroy
them," Casim says talking about having her meet his Muslim family.
‘What about your heart, and my heart?’ Roisin replies.
Casim tells her
that he has personally seen the racism directed towards his family and
believes that adherence to his culture's values is the community's
best hope for survival. Nonetheless, he tells his mother to cancel the
arranged wedding and decides to move in with Roisin even though he
knows the ramifications it will have the community. Things start to
get tough for Roisin as well. She learns that she is in line for a
full time position at the school if she can gain the approval of her
parish priest (Gerard Kelly but he has other thoughts. In a scene that
will make you duck to avoid the flying sparks, he berates Roisin for
'living in sin" with a non-Catholic while still married and refuses to
give his approval unless she leaves Casim.
To complicate matters further, Casim's sister
Rukhsana visits Roisin and also asks her to leave him. Roisin,
however, tells her that she loves her brother and Rukhsana replies, "I
know but for how long? I don't know how typical Casim's family's
reaction is to his relationship with a "goree" (white girl) but Loach
shows them without any willingness to give an inch. One wishes that
there was a solution that would make both parties happy but such is
not the case. The parents will not
acknowledge that their children are living in a different world or
encourage them to make their own choices. On the other hand, Roisin
can only see the problem in terms of her own needs and desires.
A Fond Kiss may not be Loach's best work but it is very real
and involving and one of the few that ends on an optimistic note.
Though the story of star-crossed lovers has been told before, it has
rarely been related with as much honesty, insight, and beauty.
Film
Grade: A-
Home | Back to Top |