|
Saraband
(2005)
Starring:
Gunnel Fred, Liv Ullmann, Erland Josephson
Director:
Ingmar Bergman
Rating: R
Distributor:
Sony Pictures Classics
Release Date:
07.08.05
Review
Posted:
07.25.05
By
Howard Schumann
Originally shot for
television in high definition video, Ingmar Bergman's latest film,
Saraband, is about the reunion of a husband and wife after thirty
years of divorce and separation. Divided into ten segments plus a
prologue and epilogue, the title is derived from a minuet-like dance
for two people commonly performed at court during the 17th
and 18th centuries. Like the dance, there are never more
than two people on screen at any one time and the film is almost all
conversation with bits of classical music. The film is vintage Bergman
with revealing close-ups, emotionally intense dialogue, an
old-fashioned style of filmmaking, and a surfeit of bitterness about
the human condition.
Liv Ullman and
Erland Josephson, the original screen couple from Bergman's 1973 film
Scenes of a Marriage, reunite in his summer home for their
first face to face contact since their breakup. Johan has become very
wealthy as a result of an inheritance. Marianne is a lawyer and they
have two daughters from their failed marriage: Sara who is married to
a prominent lawyer and lives in Australia and Martha who is in a
mental institution and does not recognize her mother. Johan is
surprised by his ex-wife's visit but they still hold hands and try to
remember the good things about the past, though Johan's interest seems
to be minimal. Living nearby are Henrik (Borje Ahlstedt), Johan's son
from a second marriage and his daughter Karin (Julia Dufvenius), a
promising young cellist. Henrik and Karin have an uncomfortably strong
attachment and mutual need as a result of the recent death of Anna,
Henrik's wife who was deeply loved.
Henrik is training
his daughter in the cello to prepare her for an audition at the local
conservatory but has to turn to Johan for financial support who uses
the occasion to humiliate him. Karin is contemplating going to Europe
to work for an orchestra but is afraid of the consequences for Henrik
if she leaves. Relationships between the family are strained,
seemingly beyond repair and their world is filled with childish
resentments and regrets. Karin resents her father for suffocating her
emotionally. Marianne still resents Johan for his unfaithfulness.
Henrik resents his father for -- not being a father. Johan resents
Henrik for not being the son he wanted. No one can see beyond their
ego to feel the needs and wants of others. The emotional pain is real
but I found the end result to be facile and unconvincing.
Saraband
has received
high praise as a "lacerating examination of life's conundrums that is
exhilarating in its fearlessness and its command", and an "affective,
touching, and ultimately highly affirming picture of familial turmoil
and the curative, as well as destructive, powers of love." But what I
ask is this - What new insights do we gain about the human condition
from witnessing a family go at each other with unbridled ruthlessness?
In offering his audience the latest generation of "emotional
illiterates", Bergman lets us see the clawing and fighting but hides
the life-affirming reality that people are capable of transcending
their limitations.
In Saraband,
there is no self- reflection, responsibility, or hint that people can
change with the passage of time. His characters only seem to have been
able to refine their capacity for collecting grievances. When Henrik
is suffering, no one talks about him, goes to visit him, or seems in
the least concerned. Is this the way Bergman after all these years
sees human relationships? Is this the legacy he wants to leave us?
Despite its considerable strengths, Sourband (sic) is a bitter
and despairing film that left a bad taste in my mouth.
Film
Grade: B-
Home | Back to Top |