|
Touching the
Void
(2004)
Starring:
Nicholas Aaron,
Brendan Mackey, Joe Simpson
Director:
Kevin MacDonald
Rating: Not Rated
Studio: IFC
Films
Release Date:
01.23.04
Review
Posted: 01.23.04
Spoilers:
Minor
By
Sara M. Fetters
Soaring, Intense "Void" Nothing
to Despair
In 1985, climbers Joe Simpson and
Simon Yates set out to climb a mountain. Not just any would do,
however, the duo setting their sights on the supposedly
unconquerable west face of the Siula Grande in the Peruvian
Andes. Young, fit and full of determination, they braved the
harsh conditions and their own ill planning and managed to make
the peak after a three-day ascent. A successful climb, to be
sure, if only that pesky descent didn’t still lie in front of
them.
That is where
disaster horrifically struck, Simpson falling a short distance and
breaking several bones in his leg. With no hope of rescue, Yates
bravely tried to slide his compatriot off the mountain, lowering him
down the face of Siula Grande 300 feet at a time. Stuck in a white out
and with his partner too far out in front of him to know what was
going on, Yates found himself being slowly pulled off the mountain by
the suddenly motionless Simpson. Faced with an inhuman choice, the
climber had to either break the cardinal rule of climbing and cut the
tether between himself and his partner or leave the rope alone and be
dragged to certain death.
Needless to
say, Yates cut the rope and made the long trek back to base camp alone
wrestling with the demons ushered on by his choice. But, unbeknownst
to the crestfallen mountaineer, Joe survived his fall, landing in a
crevasse as big as the dome of St. Paul’s Cathedral. Resting on a tiny
ledge, it soon becomes clear to Simpson that the only way he’s going
to survive this adventure is if he does it alone. Refusing to give
into frostbite or extreme dehydration, the climber wills himself –
crawling one painful inch at a time most of the way – down the
mountain.
The new film
from Academy Award-winning documentarian Kevin Macdonald (“One Day in
September”) “Touching the Void” is a blisteringly intense examination
of Simpson and Yates story. Based on Joe’s award-winning book of the
same name, Macdonald fuses present-day interviews of the climbers with
surreal reenactments of the events to craft a documentary unlike
almost any other I’ve ever seen. It is a beautifully rendered
document, a testament to human perseverance and the strength of
character that resides in some individuals when faced with the specter
of certain death.
It is actually
a little amazing just how quickly this movie puts Hollywood adventures
like “Cliffhanger” and “Vertical Limit” to shame. This is an
in-your-face documentary, Macdonald and cinematographer Mike Eley
getting so close to the viscerally imperious mountain that I could
almost feel the frost on my face and my throat parched with thirst.
The reenactments are so good, so imbued with a profound intimacy, that
I couldn’t stop my palms from sweating almost from the very first
moment Simpson and Yates start the ascent up Siula Grande. Their
cockiness as they weather their first night on the mountain was
catching, as was the extreme exuberance of success upon their reaching
the summit.
But it is
Simpson, faced with the titular void, which takes the breath away. The
sight of the wounded climber hung limp over the side of the mountain,
the misty blackness beneath calling out for his blood, is the type of
moment that burns the screen with intimate power. Macdonald holds the
scene with a wretched beauty then suddenly the floor drops away and
Joe falls into the all-consuming blackness. It is a stunning,
lump-in-your-throat event, and Macdonald and company stage it
brilliantly.
Granted, the
mystery of whether or not he and Yates will survive is taken away the
moment each of their faces show up in close-up to talk about their
days on the mountain. These interviews, while utterly fascinating, due
have the unfortunate effect of diluting some of the film’s powerful
spell. This is especially so when the best the duo can come up with to
explain why they climbed is to state, “we climb because it was fun,”
not exactly the most profound words ever uttered in a documentary.
Also,
Macdonald does tend to over-direct. There is a moment late where the
director tries every trick in the book to dramatize Simpson’s growing
dehydrated hysteria. The problem is, all the jumpy camera moves and
film pixilation doesn’t put the viewer in the climber’s place; it just
gives them a headache.
I did like his
use of a rather annoying British pop song (every time a song is stuck
in my head I’ll think of this movie), though, and problems like those
are few and far between. Both Simpson and Yates are extremely
interesting, and the emotions these two feel almost two-decades later
towards the event are palpable in many of their responses. No picture
has ever quite grasped the immediacy and dangerous excitement of
mountain climbing like this one.
During a Q&A session after the film, Simpson expressed he wanted to
make, “the best climbing film I’ve ever seen.” Well, I can’t speak for
him (I assume he approves), but for my money “Touching the Void” is
even more than that, raising the already high bar of exemplary
documentary filmmaking to another level.
Film Rating:
êêê1/2 (out of 4)
Home | Back to Top |